To Give or Not to Give: Exploring the Notion of ‘Charity’

With the Christmas season fast approaching, it got me thinking about how the desire to give increases exponentially in December. In fact, half of the general public say that they donate to charity over the festive period, compared to only 34% that do it year-round. Obviously the goal should be to consistently help, and I wondered if the way we define charity could contribute to this. So how has charity been viewed philosophically over the years? And which way is right?

In the Cambridge Dictionary, charity is defined both as :

‘an organization whose purpose is to give money, food, or help to those who need it… and not to make a profit’, and

‘help, especially in the form of money, given freely to people who are in need’.

We’re going to be focusing specifically on the second definition. The idea of giving freely suggests that acting charitable shouldn’t be forced upon us: we should choose to help out of our own free will. Normatively, though, do we have a duty to perform acts of charity, freely or not?

Peter Singer seems to think so, stating that:

‘If it is in our power to prevent something bad from happening, without thereby sacrificing anything of comparable moral importance, we ought morally to do it’.

Basically, we should act so as to prevent bad things and promote good things, unless by acting, we would end up sacrificing something more important or doing something just as bad. So, if you see a homeless man on the street, you ought morally to give him money and/or food (or help in some other means). Yes, you would be sacrificing some of your money and/or food, but this is insignificant compared to the very bad state of the homeless man, who has no money or food whatsoever and could be at risk of starvation or even death. Therefore, Singer might be advocating for an abolition of the distinction between ‘duty’ and ‘charity’, arguing that charity is a moral absolute that we must do when we can, even if it costs giving up certain luxuries.

If he was still alive to contribute to this debate, Kant may have said something similar. According to Peter Atterton, Kant would say that:

‘If we are able to do an act of the kind prescribed by the imperfect duty of beneficence, then we ought, morally, to do it unless, in the same circumstances, we perform some other act of the kind prescribed by imperfect (or perfect) duties’. Let’s break this down. 

An imperfect duty for Kant is one where its avoidance can technically be universalised (made into a universal law), but we wouldn’t want it to, thus leading to a contradiction of the will. The idea of a selfish world, where we only help people if it benefits ourselves, could become universal law but you would not want to will it so, as there are many times where we might need the sympathy and help of others. Therefore, we have an imperfect duty of beneficence (actively producing good/acting in the best interests of others).

Kant’s view of charity as a duty may be slightly more selective than Singer’s ‘we must help people wherever we can, whenever we can’ approach. Kant defines a perfect duty as ‘one which allows no exception in the interest of inclination’ (4:421/pg. 35) – this suggests then that imperfect duties do. So, although it is impermissible to refuse to help others on principle, this doesn’t necessarily mean I have a duty to help everyone who needs it. As long as I help others on at least some occasions, I will have done my duty.

My issue is that this seems like quite a self-centred view of charity. I can basically just do as I please provided that I sometimes perform the acts of beneficence that duty requires of me; and this duty is required because not doing so leads to a contradiction of the will since I might need help at some point in my life. But Kant ends up establishing a much stronger principle when discussing his second maxim – always treat people not as a means, but as an ends in themselves. This maxim can also be used to establish our duty of beneficence, as we must treat humanity positively as an end-in-itself, and as a matter of contributing to each other’s ‘happiness’. Kant claims that in order to fully respect others, we must do everything we can to promote their ends – this is an ethical/ ‘wide’ duty. But this doesn’t mean we can make exceptions to the maxim; only that we can limit one maxim by another. So if the wide duty of acting towards the welfare of others clashes with a legal/’narrow’ duty to promote a different end  (e.g. refraining from stealing).  Thus, I have an ethical duty to give food to the homeless man unless I would have to steal the food to give to him, since I have a legal duty to refrain from stealing. It’s not about our personal preference, just what we can, and should do in the moment.

So it seems that charity should be re-established as a duty, rather than an innate desire or inclination, since a lot of what we think to be ‘charity’ is actually duty anyway. But is this true?

Sociologist Edward Westermarck may beg to differ, as he argued that social institutions are rooted in moral emotions. He looked at family, stating that the duty of parents to take care of their children is based on the sentiment of parental affection that they already have. When looking beyond the family, you can see that mutual aid is extended in a diluted form to wider circles of men and eventually towards the entire community. Humans have evolved to feel sympathy for and want to assist others; this sympathy can be released by certain symbols and behaviours, but the sentiment is already present. So the idea of charity being a ‘duty’ is only because the habitual practice of mutual aid is based on altruistic sentiment in the first place. 

Obviously there are issues with this approach. Westermarck may be operating on a slightly too optimistic view on human nature and sympathy. Many philosophers argue that humans are completely selfish creatures, so surely then there would be no altruistic sentiment for charity to act off. This could be particularly true in the 21st Century, with commercialisation potentially causing people to be more solitary and detached from others, caring only for profits. People are probably more likely to treat others as a mere means just to get ahead. But isn’t it such a nice idea to think that we help people because we genuinely want to? It’s not some duty that we must perform; we don’t do it because we might need the favour returned one day. We do it because we truly care about others. Whether this is true or not is up for debate, but I think it’s a valuable sentiment to keep in our society. Maybe the solution is to view charity as a mix of both: it is a duty we should perform because we care for others. Either way, let’s all try to be more charitable all year long. Don’t save it all for Christmas.

Image credits: https://www.thebubble.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/food_bank_giving_quote.jpg

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *