Changing the Rules of the Game – Debunking the Myth of the ‘Perfect Student’

It’s easy to forget that there is no such thing as the ‘perfect student’. A lot of us join university straight from A-Levels, and so we’re still stuck in the ‘all or nothing’ mindset. Coming from a system where a handful of exams can influence your entire future, it’s instinctive to apply the same attitude to your degree. That every lecture, seminar and assignment is something you’re being tested on. That every single second counts, and that one bad day could ruin everything you’ve worked for. As soon as the term began, I was bombarded with (well-meaning) emails from the Careers office and my departments and miscellaneous articles all shouting about how employment rates are down (spoiler alert – they pretty much always say that). That I had to get started, right now, because I was already behind. 

Personally, I was extremely overwhelmed by all of this, and then instantly ashamed of being overwhelmed instead of accomplishing it all with ease. It wasn’t until I spoke to friends that I understood: we all feel overwhelmed when we get those emails. The idea we have of this ‘perfect student’ who has it all together, all the time. It isn’t real. They don’t exist. In my experience, it can be difficult to tell that to the voice in your head. For whatever reason, most things are easier to hear coming from someone else.

So, this is me, breaking the fourth wall, telling the crowd: I do not have it all together, pretty much ever. There is always something that I’m on top of and something that I am behind on. And that is okay. In fact, that is entirely normal. 

It’s like we think that if we admit to struggling, the façade will shatter and suddenly everyone will know that you have failed at being perfect. I used to be one of those people. (I attribute this predisposition to my time at an all-girls grammar school) But then I realised that dedicating so much energy to pretending is exhausting. The worst part of clinging to this performance of perfection is the isolation. You become convinced that everyone else is in on something you’re not and that no one will understand what you’re going through, and so you must pretend you too are in on it, or they will all see you for what you really are – not good enough. The irony is that everyone you’re looking at, wishing you were them, is looking at someone else, wishing the same thing. It seems to me that if we were all honest with each other, we’d feel a lot less alone and realise that there is a difference between losing the game and deciding to change the rules.

With the summative season fully underway and the second-year scare sinking in, I’m here to tell you (and myself) that it’s okay to not have it all together. It’s okay to take a day in bed if you’re sick or sad, have a slow morning, or go out with friends instead of going to the library. And you can do all of that and still be someone who works hard and achieves things and deserves to be here. It’s good for you to take a breather and make time for something that isn’t going on your CV.

And yes, you are in university to work hard and begin the path towards whatever you want for your future, but whilst doing all of this, you need to remember that you are here, right now. The friends met, memories made, and lessons learned; these are all just as important as your degree and job prospects. Learning to look after yourself, and to prioritise what you need, not just what you’re trying to achieve. That matters too.

My housemates and I have developed a seasonal post-dinner tradition: watching the best television has to offer, the Netflix Christmas rom-coms (Catering Christmas – I hated you). It’s time when we’re not doing anything towards achieving a first or increasing our chances of securing an internship. We just laugh and shout and gasp at the plot twist we all knew was coming. Whether it’s joining our tradition or creating one of your own, I recommend finding something like that.

It’s easy to become convinced that life is a game and that the only way to win is by working yourself to the bone. I propose a different tactic: ask yourself, are you sure that the key to success is playing by the competition’s rules? Or is the real victory found in learning to make your own? Take some time to think about what winning really means to you, or if life is about winning at all. For me, success used to be defined by whether I had the highest grades or logged the most hours on Flora. Now, I know that there will be times when I don’t have it all together, but in the long run, I can keep what matters most. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *